Archive for Hybrids and introgressants

Jan
11

Hoodarrion Crows

Posted by: Rick Wright | Comments (1)

These fine crows had found a great place to bathe in Vienna’s Stadpark. I felt a bit like one of Susannah’s elders spying on them, but there’s something unusual about these birds: I have no idea what they are.

And neither, in a sense, do they.

Lower Austria’s breeding “black” crow is the handsome gray Hooded Crow, much like this one facing off with a European Red Squirrel in the Schönbrunn gardens last week.

Come winter, though, all identification bets are off. Carrion Crow genes course through the blood of many, perhaps of most, of the thousands of non-Rook, non-Jackdaw Corvus roosting and feeding in the city, producing some handsome combinations of plumages.

Dark birds like this one might pass for a Carrion Crow on casual inspection, but the gray thighs and nape gave it away as a hybrid or intergrade; its exact heritage is likely very complex, full of the crosses and backcrosses typical of these birds in Mitteleuropa.

Many superficially Hooded Crows also showed clear signs of mixed ancestry, with extra black appearing most frequently on the mantle and lesser coverts.

With so many of these Hoodarrion Crows around, the suspicion is unavoidable that even visually “pure” birds aren’t. But–and this is the important point–who cares? We’re stuck enjoying what’s out there, and if it’s crows with fascinatingly muddy bloodlines, so much the better.

  • Share/Bookmark
Nov
06

Black Mallards

Posted by: Rick Wright | Comments (0)

A wonderful day at Brigantine yesterday, just the two of us. Well, just the three of us if you count Gellert asleep in the back of the car.

Alison and I saw lots of birds, including two Hudsonian Godwits and five Snow Buntings; wonder whether they knew each other from back home in the Arctic!

As expected on a chilly November day, waterfowl were abundant. Most of the thousands of ducks out on the big pools were Northern Pintail and American Black Ducks, but looking close turned up another dozen anatid species–and plenty of birds like these.

The bird on the right here looks black-duck-ish enough, but not so the pair in front of him. To call them “hybrids” would be to oversimplify things: who can tell how many mixed pairs of mallard-like ducks are in their family tree?

Especially the drake was a very handsome bird, all chocolate brown with a beautiful bronzy nape and that elegant little duck tail.

If you’re lucky enough to see American Black Ducks with any frequency, keep an eye out; it’s the rare flock that doesn’t include at least a few of these obvious introgressants.

  • Share/Bookmark

The AOU Committee on Classification and Nomenclature will not re-split Mexican Duck from (Northern) Mallard in the forthcoming Supplement to the Check-list.

The “no” votes acknowledge that Mexican Duck may indeed be more closely related to the Mottled Ducks and to American Black Duck than to the good ol’ greenhead, but the major obstacle to recognition at the species level seems to be the frequency of hybridization and introgression between the two.

Not, of course, that Northern Mallards won’t breed with anything feathered they can outswim. McCarthy quotes C.L. Sibley as saying that “in a mixed collection of waterfowl the Mallard is an unmitigated nuisance because of the amorousness of the males,” then goes on to list something like 60 documented hybrids involving that species.

One of the commonest and best-known combinations is that with American Black Duck, probably not much less frequent than mixes with Mexican Duck.

This male was in Mercer Co., New Jersey, a couple of autumns ago; his eye is obviously on creating a little more genetic complexity with that Mallard hen.

In any event, the AOU committee’s endorsement of the taxonomic status quo seems to reflect not just a dissatisfaction with the evidence, but perhaps–to push the point a little–the lack of a species concept that can accommodate things like mallards and juncos and fox sparrows and big gulls. Biological reality is messy, and we may have to give up the notion of the species entirely if we’re to figure out how to describe it. Seems to me like we’ve known that since about 1859, but old habits of thought die hard!

  • Share/Bookmark
Mar
13

A Hybrid Wigeon?

Posted by: Rick Wright | Comments (2)

It’s hard in the colder half of the year not to see flocks of American Wigeon around Vancouver. And dumpy little ponds like this one, surrounded by lawn and houses and Saturday morning joggers, seem to be their preferred habitat.

A quick scan of a flock this large is almost guaranteed to turn up a Eurasian Wigeon or two. And sure enough, one of the first birds Alison and I saw when we pulled up to Centennial Beach yesterday morning was a nice gray drake with a nice red head.

But was it really a Eurasian Wigeon?

Like all ducks, the wigeon are given to miscegenation, and every one of the three species–American, Eurasian, and Chiloe–has hybridized with each of the others, not to mention with virtually every other species of puddle duck.

The Centennial Beach bird struck us as a candidate for such a hybrid or back-cross.

There was a definite pinkish tone to the sides, and the head color was decidedly dull, with a noticeably “faded” effect to the cheek beneath the eye; the eye patch was also very conspicuous. From certain angles, I think I could see a faint, incomplete black line at the base of the bill. The wing coverts seemed to be entirely bright white, eliminating the possibility that we were dealing with just a smudgy first-cycle male.

Hybrid wigeon are over-reported in North America; too many birders see a green eye patch or a blurry flank or a dull forehead blaze and immediately assume that it couldn’t be a “pure” Eurasian–an assumption they’d be less eager to make after a few hours with a flock of Eurasians in the Old World. This time, though, I’m willing to believe that there may well be some American blood coursing through these veins.

What do you think?

  • Share/Bookmark

Is there anything more glorious than a wild Mallard drake in his basic (=breeding =winter =bright =fancy) plumage? And the hens, though more muted, are every bit as beautiful, too.

In a way, it’s too bad that this species is so incredibly abundant and so familiar to most of us. It’s sometimes just too easy to look right past Mallards in our search for something “better,” and we wind up ignoring some things–like the bright blue secondaries–that would take our breath away in a bird less common and less quotidian.

Watching Mallards is, in fact, one of the most exciting ways a birder can spend her time: not only are they pretty, but they’re given to shamelessness in most of their behaviors, letting human eyes behold all sorts of avian activities usually conducted in private. Preening, bathing, feeding, and every stage of courtship from soup to nuts: all out on display.

It gets even better. While we often think of a big flock as just the backdrop to the star rarities we’re looking for, large congregations of Mallards are in fact anything but monolithic. Even when the search turns up no vagrants–and statistically speaking, that’s going to be most of the time–there’s almost always a “different” bird among the Mallards themselves, a hybrid or an intergrade or, heaven help us, a barnyard duck.

As the English name “Mallard” suggests, these ducks are nothing if not promiscuous, and in the heat of the moment, drakes will mate with anything with feathers. The most commonly observed hybrids are, as one might expect, those with closely related taxa such as American Black Duck (above, in New Jersey) or Mexican Duck (below, in Arizona).

Sometimes things get really out of hand, and the result can be something like this, a Mallard x Northern Pintail hybrid in British Columbia.

More frequently we run across birds that don’t really fit any of the categories of thought we birders work within. And that’s because they aren’t really “wild” in the sense of the field guides. Mallards have been domesticated for thousands of years, and their sense of adventure means that such birds–bred for meat, for eggs, for ornament and companionship–regularly escape to join their wild cousins on lakes and ponds. And many populations of “feral” Mallards receive a regular infusion of new blood every Easter Monday, when it is discovered that ducklings possess not just adorability but digestive tracts.

Many of these birds–lately, it seems, described with the none too delicate adjective “manky,” a nicely alliterative coinage by Charlie Moores–are immediately recognizable as Mallards of a sort.

This very pretty bird, for example, might be mistaken for a genuine wild Mallard at a glance–he’s even got the species’ trademark “ducktail,” a feature retained in most domestic Mallard drakes–but the head shape is strange, and the plumage is oddly yellowish throughout. Somewhere in this bird’s pedigree we’re almost certain to find a domestic forebear of the breed known, aptly, as Buff.

Other individuals can lead to confusion. I’ve heard birders seriously weigh the possibility that a white-bibbed Mallard–a feature conspicuous in several domestic breeds–was in fact an eider.

And call ducks, the tiniest and cutest breed of domestic Mallard going, are continually misidentified as leucistic wigeon, thanks to their short necks, round heads, and diminutive bills.

There are dozens of domestic breeds of Mallard that can be seen “in the wild,” from bizarre runners

to equally weird crested ducks.

What they all have in common is that they’re Mallards–just like a cocker spaniel or a Labradoodle is a dog, just like an American beauty is a rose. It’s pretty amazing what a few millennia of selective breeding can do!

Check 10000 Birds for a growing gallery of domestic and just plain bizarre Mallards.

  • Share/Bookmark
Comments (8)

 Subscribe in a reader

Nature Blog Network