Archive for Famous Birders
Jon Dunn on the Ivory-billed Woodpecker
Posted by: | CommentsIt’s very sad, but the latest report of the ABA Checklist Committee probably sums it up: there’s no evidence whatsoever that the Ivory-billed Woodpecker survives.
And here’s what the new, sixth edition of the National Geographic Field Guide has to say:
…intense searching subsequently [after the April 2005 announcement] has yet to produce more documentation, [a circumstance] seemingly not possible in an age when most rarities discovered are photographed and those images are posted on the Internet the same day…. sightings that lack provable evidence more likely represent wishful thinking.
The seventh edition will see that fine bird relegated to the appendix shared by Eskimo Curlew, Bachman’s Warbler, and Labrador Duck.
Oh, to have been born 150 years earlier! No, never mind.
Over at the ABA Blog Today
Posted by: | CommentsA brief, informal review of the new NatGeo.
My advice: buy it!
Cooper, Wilson, and Trudeau Walk Onto a Bar…
Posted by: | Comments… a sandbar, that is, on the coast of New Jersey. What could they possibly find to talk about?

What Alexander Wilson, William Cooper, and James Trudeau have in common is that each provides the eponym for a bird first described from a New Jersey specimen.
Wilson gets a plover and a warbler. Cooper gets a hawk. And Trudeau, said by Audubon to have come from Louisiana (the sources make no mention of any banjo on his knee), is memorialized in the English and scientific names of a tern.

Trudeau’s Tern, now also known as Snowy-crowned Tern, presents a unique case in the history of North American ornithology. Audubon, in his description of the species in the Ornithological Biography, says that his “much esteemed and talented friend” had collected the bird he painted from a group of a few birds found at Great Egg Harbor, now in Atlantic County. Thus, the type locality for the species is Great Egg Harbor, New Jersey.
But here’s where it gets strange. The AOU Check-list Committee, after the species had been included for well over a century in the authentic avifauna of North America, removed it in the Seventh Edition to the appendix of “Species reported from the A.O.U. check-list area with insufficient evidence for placement on the main list.” As a result, Sterna trudeaui is cited from a type locality in North America–but not admitted to the North American list, thanks to doubts about the bird’s provenance.
I don’t know that there is a parallel case anywhere in the history of ornithological nomenclature. Can you think of one?
Thanks to Ted and to Jennifer.
Cento: What Hollywood Tells Us
Posted by: | CommentsI’ll probably see The Big Year eventually; I thought the book, for all its stubbornly manifest inaccuracies, was very funny in places, and Steve Martin is one of my favorites.
For now, though, what I’m finding fascinating is the rare opportunity to look at birding from the outside, as critics and reviewers explain the phenomenon to their non-birding readers. So here’s what we apparently look like to “normal” people:
Bird-watching seems like a harmless hobby, and I’ve penciled it into the calendar for my golden years. - Joe Williams
For most of the general population the only thing more boring than birding itself is watching other people do it. - Robert Levin
True, birding may be a solitary, insular pursuit, only important to those who enjoy its meek geek attributes. – Bill Gibron
Bird-watching — or birding, as practitioners prefer to call it — makes for a stupefyingly boring movie. – Rene Rodriguez
Maybe it’s impossible to make anything really interesting, on a subject that is itself so inherently uninteresting. - Joshua Tyler
Aside from an international staring contest and the World Series of Texting, there aren’t many challenges less suited for a movie than competitive bird watching. – Matt Pais
People with plenty of disposable income travel to locales on a moment’s notice whenever they hear of an unusual or uncommon species that has decided to land on a branch or a rock or a beach …. setting up tripods in garbage dumps, hunkering down for long hours in the woods and making silly sounds with one’s lips. – Teddy Durgin
Competitive birding is only for the leisure class or for young people sponsored by their rich, indulgent parents. - James Verniere
A long, slightly dull slog …. But then, that’s birding for you. – Stephen Whitty
An asinine sort-of sport. – Dustin Putman





